¿Tienen las momias egipcias derecho a la privacidad?
- Michael Cook
- 20 / 09 / 2010
La investigación con muestras de tejidos en cadáveres ha sido ampliamente discutida, dando lugar a estrictos lineamientos éticos; la manipulación de restos humanos antiguos, en cambio, no ha corrido con la misma suerte. En un artículo publicado recientemente en el “Semanario de Ética Médica”, el anatomista Frank Ruhli y la eticista Ina Kaufmann, ambos de la Universidad de Zurich, sostienen que la investigación en momias es invasiva, ya que revela información acerca de la historia familiar y condiciones médicas del sujeto momificado, quién si bien no se encuentra en condiciones de prestar su consentimiento, debería sin duda ser tratado con respeto.
Ruhli, quien está actualmente involucrado en una investigación con momias egipcias dice al respecto: “El cuerpo humano, vivo o muerto, posee un valor moral”; y por ello sostiene que los investigadores deben contrastar los beneficios que derivarían de sus investigaciones en relación con los derechos individuales y deseos del muerto, sin que la antigüedad de la muerte vaya en detrimento de su valor moral intrínseco.
Desde una perspectiva diferente, Franco Rollo, de la Universidad de Camerino, Italia, se opone a estas consideraciones basándose en la autoridad que le confiere el haber trabajado con Otzi, el hombre de hielo –quién murió hace 5.000 años y cuyos restos momificados fueron encontrados en los Alpes en el año 1991. A diferencia de Kaufmann y Ruhli, este investigador considera que los planteamientos éticos resultan relativamente insignificantes si los restos en cuestión son considerados por la mayoría de la gente “lo bastante viejos como para pertenecer a una época histórica y social, sentida realmente en forma diferente y distante del presente.”
Por su parte, Soren Holm, bioeticista y filósofo de la Universidad de Manchester, Inglaterra, considera que los investigadores deberían indagar la verdadera motivación que alienta su trabajo; es decir, preguntarse si actúan movidos por un interrogante científico o simplemente por curiosidad. Sobre este punto, Holm sostiene que dada la dificultad que presenta el desarrollo de una política verdaderamente integradora, un cuestionario ético que promueva la reflexión podría resultar una estrategia de gran utilidad. En esta misma línea, Frank Ruhli considera que los científicos deberían asumir una responsabilidad personal: “Si un investigador se propone trabajar con una momia, sería importante conocer cuáles son sus reflexiones al respecto.”
Información ampliatoria en New Scientist, Sept 10; Journal of Medical Ethics, DOI: 10.1136/jme.2010.036608
COMENTARIOS
Mensaje de curry 8 » 11 de septiembre de 2022 » nzjztlqonjd@gmail.com
I just wanted to compose a simple comment so as to thank you for all the stunning tips and hints you are posting at this site. My extended internet search has at the end been compensated with beneficial strategies to exchange with my best friends. I ’d believe that many of us site visitors are truly blessed to be in a fine network with very many outstanding professionals with good guidelines. I feel really grateful to have used the webpages and look forward to many more fun times reading here. Thanks once more for a lot of things.
Mensaje de yeezy » 11 de septiembre de 2022 » xuphvdi@gmail.com
A lot of thanks for all of the effort on this blog. My daughter really likes getting into research and it’s obvious why. Many of us know all regarding the dynamic way you render simple tips and tricks on the website and in addition foster response from the others on that concept and our daughter is without a doubt studying so much. Take advantage of the remaining portion of the year. You have been performing a first class job.
Mensaje de yeezy 700 » 11 de septiembre de 2022 » ueidhcndqxi@gmail.com
My wife and i have been so peaceful Albert could finish off his inquiry through the entire ideas he made from your web page. It’s not at all simplistic to simply be handing out ideas which a number of people have been selling. And we recognize we now have the writer to appreciate for this. Those explanations you made, the easy website navigation, the friendships your site make it possible to instill - it is mostly overwhelming, and it’s leading our son in addition to the family do think this matter is thrilling, which is exceptionally fundamental. Many thanks for all the pieces!
Mensaje de off white outlet » 10 de septiembre de 2022 » tsrfapyc@gmail.com
I truly wanted to post a small comment so as to say thanks to you for these awesome tips and tricks you are showing on this site. My time intensive internet lookup has now been recognized with wonderful details to talk about with my partners. I ’d assume that we website visitors actually are undeniably endowed to be in a fantastic website with very many special professionals with very beneficial advice. I feel very much fortunate to have discovered the website and look forward to so many more cool times reading here. Thanks a lot once again for all the details.
Mensaje de bape sta » 10 de septiembre de 2022 » ncezcistw@gmail.com
My husband and i got absolutely happy Ervin could finish up his web research through the ideas he obtained from your web page. It’s not at all simplistic just to choose to be giving for free techniques which usually others may have been making money from. And we acknowledge we now have the website owner to be grateful to for that. The entire illustrations you’ve made, the straightforward website menu, the relationships your site help engender - it’s got everything extraordinary, and it’s aiding our son and the family reason why that idea is cool, which is tremendously vital. Many thanks for the whole lot!
Mensaje de kd shoes » 10 de septiembre de 2022 » ajczaxs@gmail.com
I precisely wished to thank you so much yet again. I’m not certain the things that I would have accomplished in the absence of the type of creative ideas documented by you directly on this problem. It actually was a very scary dilemma in my position, however , understanding the professional avenue you handled the issue made me to cry over contentment. I will be happier for this service as well as pray you are aware of a powerful job your are getting into instructing others with the aid of your webpage. Probably you have never got to know any of us.
Mensaje de supreme new york » 10 de septiembre de 2022 » vciikwaloyt@gmail.com
I as well as my friends appeared to be digesting the excellent procedures found on the blog then suddenly I got a horrible feeling I had not expressed respect to the site owner for those strategies. The men ended up glad to read through all of them and already have surely been taking advantage of those things. Appreciate your getting well accommodating and also for pick out certain superb ideas most people are really wanting to be aware of. My personal honest regret for not saying thanks to you earlier.
Mensaje de hermes birkin » 10 de septiembre de 2022 » xokkvpompi@gmail.com
Needed to draft you a tiny note so as to give many thanks yet again for your personal spectacular suggestions you’ve shared on this site. It has been quite surprisingly generous of you to allow extensively all most people would have sold as an e book to generate some money for their own end, particularly seeing that you might well have done it in the event you wanted. These tactics as well served to be a good way to recognize that some people have the identical dreams just like my very own to understand way more when considering this condition. I’m sure there are thousands of more pleasant occasions ahead for many who looked at your site.
Mensaje de stephen curry shoes » 9 de septiembre de 2022 » qvutgdrovlz@gmail.com
I’m also commenting to let you understand what a extraordinary discovery my wife’s girl went through reading through your webblog. She discovered numerous details, which include what it is like to have an ideal helping character to make most people very easily know just exactly a variety of specialized subject matter. You truly surpassed her expected results. Thanks for presenting these important, trusted, informative and cool thoughts on your topic to Gloria.
Mensaje de goyard tote bag » 9 de septiembre de 2022 » ggczrqqq@gmail.com
My spouse and i got very thrilled that Edward managed to do his studies with the precious recommendations he was given when using the weblog. It’s not at all simplistic to simply happen to be giving out techniques which often some other people might have been making money from. So we see we have the website owner to give thanks to for this. The type of explanations you have made, the simple website menu, the friendships you can help foster - it’s got many astonishing, and it’s really making our son and us know that the situation is thrilling, and that is quite mandatory. Thanks for everything!